How is the Value of Pain and Suffering Calculated?
Are you from Maryland and wondering how the value of pain and suffering is calculated?
It’s fairly well-known that “pain and suffering” is a common factor in calculating the damages in a personal injury settlement.
A reliable legal advocate will take your emotional damage and reduced quality of life into consideration when pursuing a settlement on your behalf. However, the layperson may find this confusing.
Other common damages like medical expenses and lost wages come with dollar amounts already attached, making calculation of damages far easier.
But how are internal factors like chronic pain and emotional trauma transmuted into dollar amounts?
Today’s blog will explain the methods employed to attach figures to feelings. Read on to demystify this complex aspect of legal compensation.
Defining Pain and Suffering Damages
Given that pain and suffering are inherently intangible concepts, you may be unsurprised to learn that there are no hard and fast rules to calculate pain and suffering.
Every personal injury situation is going to be unique, impacting the life of the injured party in different ways.
“Pain and suffering” is an umbrella term to group all non-monetary damages under one label.
These may include:
- Death of a loved one or pet
- Loss of career
- Emotional distress, especially grief and bereavement
- Chronic pain
- Long-term or permanent disability
- Disruption and inconvenience
- Mental illnesses (depression, anxiety, PTSD, insomnia, amnesia, etc.)
Given that there are relatively broad guidelines for calculating pain and suffering damages, the amount of damages will be defined in large part by the severity of the case and the skill of the negotiating attorney.
The strength of the argument composed by your legal representatives will be instrumental in determining the level of compensation you may expect.
Methods and Formulas
While factors will always be different, there are several tried and true calculation strategies used to transmute the pain and suffering of individuals into a quantifiable dollar amount.
Let’s review some of the major ones.
| Method | How It Works | Best For… | Limitations |
| Multiplier Method | Multiply total medical bills + lost wages by 1.5 to 5 based on injury severity. | Most personal injury cases. | The multiplier is arbitrary; opposing sides often disagree on the specific number. |
| Per Diem Method | Assigns a daily dollar amount for each day of recovery, usually based on the injured person’s salary. | Cases with a clear, estimated recovery period. | Unworkable for chronic or life-long injuries. |
| Algorithmic Models | Insurance companies use proprietary algorithms factoring multiple variables to calculate the final amount. | Internal insurance calculations. | Designed to minimize payouts; rarely reflects the true value of your suffering. |
The Multiplier Method
The most common and approachable method to calculate pain and suffering damages is known as the multiplier method.
To begin, take the total amount of monetary damages owed to you. This includes medical bills and lost wages.
Next, multiply that figure by a number between 1.5 and 5, based on the severity of your pain and suffering. The figure you arrive at through this equation is the value of your pain and suffering.
When selecting a multiplier, keep in mind that lower end multipliers around 1.5 are far more common.
A multiplier of 5 would indicate a permanent, life-altering degree of pain, disability, and reduced quality of life.
The major issues with the multiplier method arise from opposing negotiators disagreeing on the severity of the injury.
Indeed, given that this scale is mostly arbitrary it can be very easy for one side’s 1.5 to be a 3 or 4 when viewed from the other side.
The multiplier model also runs into problems with debilitating injuries that may not be considered “severe” in medical terms.
Treating a disfiguring scar may be cheap, but it may still account for a serious reduction in the scarred person’s quality of life.
The Per Diem Method
In situations where your recovery period can be estimated with a high degree of accuracy, it may be more efficient to employ the per diem method in calculating damages.
This method simply assigns a dollar amount to be paid out daily throughout the course of your recovery.
Usually this amount of money is calculated in relation to the injured person’s salary. For obvious reasons, per diems are usually unworkable for chronic, life-long injury.
Algorithmic Models and the Insurance Companies
While these basic models may give some idea of how calculations of pain and suffering are conducted, it’s important to keep in mind that the exact method for calculating the value of pain and suffering.
Insurance companies also maintain proprietary models for conducting these calculations based around algorithms.
These algorithms take a wide variety of factors into account to arrive at the final figure owed to the injured person. Keep in mind that this model will generally be created to save the insurance company money.
Their valuation of your pain may vary vastly from the estimate of a personal injury attorney.
Factors That Affect How Pain and Suffering Is Calculated
How pain and suffering is calculated starts with recognizing that no two personal injury cases are identical.
While the multiplier and per diem methods provide a framework, the final value of a pain and suffering claim is shaped by a combination of specific factors:
1. Severity of Physical Pain and Injuries
The more severe and debilitating the physical pain, the higher the potential pain and suffering compensation.
A broken bone that heals in six weeks will be valued very differently than a spinal injury that causes permanent nerve damage.
2. Duration of Recovery
How long you experience pain and suffering directly impacts your claim.
A short recovery period typically results in lower compensation, while an extended or lifelong recovery significantly increases the value of your pain and suffering damages.
In Maryland, documenting every stage of your recovery, through medical visits, physical therapy records, and personal journals, can strengthen your suffering claim.
-
Emotional Distress and Psychological Impact
Pain and suffering damages extend well beyond physical pain.
Emotional distress including anxiety, depression, PTSD, insomnia, and loss of enjoyment of life is a definitive component of any pain and suffering claim.
In Maryland personal injury cases, psychological evaluations and mental health treatment records can serve as evidence to support emotional distress damages.
-
Impact on Quality of Life and Daily Activities
Courts consider how your injuries have affected your ability to work, maintain relationships, engage in hobbies, and perform everyday tasks.
-
Quality and Consistency of Medical Documentation
Strong medical documentation is one of the most decisive factors in calculating pain and suffering.
Medical bills, treatment records, specialist referrals, and physician notes all help establish a clear, credible picture of your suffering.
Gaps in treatment, such as missing appointments or delaying medical care, can be used by insurance companies to argue that your injuries were not as serious as claimed, reducing your overall suffering compensation.
-
The Skill of Your Personal Injury Lawyer
Perhaps the most underestimated factor is the quality of legal representation.
An experienced pain and suffering lawyer knows how to present evidence compellingly, counter insurance company algorithms, and negotiate for a pain and suffering settlement that truly reflects the scope of your damages.
How Much Can You Recover for Pain and Suffering in Maryland?
One of the most common questions in any personal injury case is: how much is my pain and suffering claim actually worth?
The honest answer is that it depends, but understanding the typical ranges and the factors that influence them can help set realistic expectations.
How Malloy Law Can Help
Average, every day people may be put off by the idea of assigning monetary value to their pain. This is understandable.
Part of reaching maturity is the ability to minimize pain and go on with your day to day. But you should not let the insurance companies minimize your pain to protect their bottom line.
If you or a loved one has been injured through another party’s negligence, Malloy Law is here to help.
Our dedicated team of attorneys is ready to fight for maximum compensation on your behalf.
We’ll accurately assess the value of your case free of charge and aggressively negotiate on your behalf.
So don’t wait, contact Malloy Law today to get started.
FAQS
1. How is pain and suffering calculated in Maryland?
In Maryland, pain and suffering is typically calculated using one of two methods: the multiplier method or the per diem method.
2. What factors affect my pain and suffering claim?
The severity of your physical pain, the duration of your recovery, the extent of emotional distress, the impact on your daily life and career, and the quality of your medical documentation.
3. What is the average pain and suffering settlement in Maryland?
There is no fixed average for a pain and suffering settlement in Maryland, as every personal injury case is unique. In reality, settlements can range from a few thousand dollars for minor injuries to hundreds of thousands for catastrophic or permanent conditions.
4. How can Malloy Law help with my pain and suffering compensation in Maryland?
At Malloy Law, personal injury lawyers have recovered over $150 million for clients across Maryland. They accurately assess the full value of your pain and suffering damages and negotiate with insurance companies on your behalf.